Residential Development vs. Railway Yards

  • Dalila C. Giusti Jade Acoustics Inc. 45 North Rivermede Road, Suite 203, Concord, Ontario, L4K 4H1
Keywords: acoustic noise, rail yard

Abstract

A rail yard is comprised of many noise sources. Unlike a highway a rail yard does not generally emit a constant hum but rather produces separate and distinct sounds. A rail yard can have extended periods of time where no activity and consequently no sounds are evident. In the case of a complaint a rail yard is not subject to provincial noise guidelines nor to any municipal noise by-laws. In fact, most noise by-laws provide exemptions for the railways. Rail yards are federally regulated by the Canadian Transportation Act, which is administered by the Canadian Transportation Agency (CTA). While the CTA can and does enforce the act, the rail activities of the rail operators are not regulated by specific numerical limits. Rail operators are permitted to expand their activities within their boundaries without requiring any approvals. Despite this seemingly “untouchable” existence, rail yard activities are the subject of complaints and as a result of this the CTA has imposed restrictions on rail activities on a case by case basis. In the case of existing residences adjacent to rail yards, often the only mitigation is relocation of the activities and/or curtailment of the activities. Due to the nature of the operation it is often very difficult (if not impossible) and costly to curtail and/or alter the rail operations. For this reason permitting new residential development adjacent to rail yards is short sighted and may result in catastrophic consequences. As a result of many hours of sound level measurements made within rail yards and at adjacent receptors and observations of rail yard activities, we have gained a better understanding of the nature of rail yards as well as the sound levels associated with each of the activities. Understanding the operations that take place within a rail yard is important to assisting the planners, engineers and municipalities in developing comprehensive plans that do not expose residential receptors to the wide range of noises and do not expose the railways to controls that are not always practicable nor feasible. The discussion that follows provides a brief description of each of the sources, provides the sound levels of the different types of activities that take place within a rail yard and explores some mitigation options.
Published
2000-12-01
How to Cite
1.
Giusti DC. Residential Development vs. Railway Yards. Canadian Acoustics [Internet]. 2000Dec.1 [cited 2019Sep.21];28(4):38-9. Available from: https://jcaa.caa-aca.ca/index.php/jcaa/article/view/1350
Section
Proceedings of the Acoustics Week in Canada